Plans to merge 14 health boards raise Helensburgh questions

NHS health boards in Scotland could be merged <i>(Image: NHS)</i>
NHS health boards in Scotland could be merged (Image: NHS)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

HELENSBURGH and Lomond residents get health care from two different regions - so how could that change under a proposed Scottish Government overhaul?

Plans to merge 14 health boards into just two - east and west - have started to raise questions about what could come next.

But politicians and the health and social care partnership (HSCP) say it is too early to know who will run what.

Acute services for the area are run by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. But community-based health is managed through Argyll and Bute HSCP, which is part of NHS Highland.

When proposals were made to restore a fourth pharmacy to Helensburgh, the decision was made in Inverness. But some pharmacy services are also provided from Glasgow.

The HSCP told the Advertiser the area is served by long-standing "service level agreements" between the health boards.

That includes services such as health visiting, community nursing, allied health professionals, maternity services and social care.

Acute hospital visits are at Glasgow hospitals and the Royal Alexandra Hospital.

A spokesperson for the HSCP said: "Residents may receive community services managed by NHS Highland, access hospital treatment through NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde facilities and be supported by some corporate services delivered through cross-board arrangements.

"Given the ongoing discussions around NHS reform, it is important to note that no decisions have yet been made regarding any future organisational arrangements.

"We are therefore unable to comment on what any new structures might look like, but the current arrangements reflect the integrated model that has operated in Helensburgh and Lomond since responsibility for community health and social care services transferred to the Argyll and Bute HSCP (part of NHS Highland)."

MSP Jackie Baillie, acting leader of Scottish Labour, said her party had proposed cutting health boards a decade ago.

She welcomed the Scottish Government's "belated conversion", but claimed the plan lacks clarity.

"The problem is that the SNP has no idea of how to do it and seem more intent on using this as a means of saving money rather than creating transformational change," she said.

“Instead of focusing on improving patient outcomes and shifting the balance of care so that more is delivered in local communities, this is more to do with saving money.

“As ever the SNP has started with a headline but has no real idea of how to deliver this change.”

John Swinney said in an interview he didn't know how many jobs would be cut from the reorganisation. He said patients would not have to travel further for treatment as a result.

He told the BBC: "What I want to make sure is that by removing health board boundaries we can maximise the number of local services that can be provided as close to home as possible for individuals in different parts of the country.

"What we've got to work our way through is a programme of reform to make sure that we put people right at the very centre of the delivery of public services so they can see the enhancement in the provision of those services in their localities."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos